News

Oct 27 2009

Deceased farmers got USDA payments

Study faults lack of case reviews

The U.S. Department of Agriculture distributed $1.1 billion over seven years to the estates or companies of deceased farmers and routinely failed to conduct reviews required to ensure that the payments were properly made, according to a government report.

In a selection of 181 cases from 1999 to 2005, the Government Accountability Office found that officials approved payments without any review 40 percent of the time.

The report cited a 1,900-acre soybean and corn farm in Illinois that collected $400,000 on behalf of an owner who lived in Florida before his death in 1995. The company did not notify the government of the death but certified each year that the dead shareholder, who owned 40 percent of the company, was "actively engaged" in managing the farm.

Most estates are allowed to collect farm payments for up to two years after an owner's death, giving heirs time to restructure their businesses and probate the will. After that, local USDA officials must certify every year that the estate is still farming and has remained open for reasons other than simply collecting subsidies.

But the GAO report found that the Agriculture Department depends on heirs and businesses to alert the agency to deaths and does not use other sources, such as Social Security records, to confirm eligibility. The report was prepared at the request of Sen. Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa), a frequent critic of large subsidies to wealthy farms. It is expected to be publicly released Tuesday at a Senate Finance Committee hearing.

"Farm payments are meant for those who need some help getting through the tough times," Grassley said last week. "Clearly there are loopholes that should be closed and laws that need to be followed."

In a letter responding to the GAO report, the Agriculture Department said that the payments were not necessarily examples of fraud or abuse and that auditors did not prove any specific cases of cheating. The department's field offices defended the practice of routinely paying dead farmers' estates without fully investigating the claims, citing staff shortages and competing priorities. The agency also said that any overpayments would amount to less than 1 percent of farm subsidies paid between 1999 and 2005.

GAO auditors found that in addition to the 40 percent of cases not reviewed by the USDA, 38 percent had "weaknesses," including "nonexistent or vague" documentation. The GAO said it could not determine from its examination whether the government improperly overpaid the estates or how much any excess might be.

An Indiana corporation that was owned entirely by one person never notified the government of the owner's death in 1993 and continued to collect unspecified payments for a decade before new owners filed for farm benefits. The government made $567,000 in payments to an Alabama estate over seven years on behalf of an owner who died in 1981. Another estate continued to receive unspecified payments on behalf of a person who died in 1973 -- more than three decades ago -- without any investigation or review.

The GAO said it found that five executors of estates had simply told the government they wanted to keep the estates open, without further explanation. Local officials in one Georgia county, in one action during a routine meeting without any investigation, approved payments for 107 people who had died more than two years earlier. GAO auditors found 10 additional cases in which subsidies were "approved for payments without any indication that even a cursory review had been conducted."

Making database checks against a list of people reported as dead to the Social Security Administration "to verify that an individual receiving farm payments has not died is a simple, cost-effective method," the GAO said. The Agriculture Department said it has asked all field offices to review the eligibility of estates and plans to begin conducting database checks.

The GAO report said that, in some cases, people who had reached the annual limit on farm subsidies of $360,000 to an individual were able to collect additional money as a beneficiary of an estate.

In its response, the Agriculture Department acknowledged that large farming operations, often formed by members of an extended family, could exceed the payment limits by keeping an estate active years after a death.

The report follows a 2004 GAO study for Grassley highlighting loopholes in the payment limits. That report found that large farming operations, organized into webs of partnerships and corporations, can legally collect far more than the $360,000 limit. More than two-thirds of the $1.1 billion in payments to estates and companies of dead people went through such entities.

Grassley plans to ask the Internal Revenue Service to investigate whether corporations and partnerships that do not inform farm programs of deaths are paying enough in taxes. Estates are taxed at a higher rate than some businesses. The senator also wants to know whether the IRS was similarly unaware of the deaths.

Grassley said that "those who might be willing to game the USDA and the federal Treasury" would get an unfair tax advantage.

Last year, a Washington Post investigation of farm subsidies found more than $15 billion in wasteful or redundant spending in other farm payments, including $1.3 billion to people who do not farm and $817 million to farms that use loopholes to exceed limits.


Date Title
10/30/09 Blue Ridge Parkway Association to receive National Park Service funding
10/30/09 St. Augustine's 450th shaping up
10/30/09 Chamber members heading for China
10/30/09 Princeton caboose hits the road today
10/30/09 Spruce-up effort possible for Franklin Street Station in Reading
10/30/09 Misspent Homeland Security money
10/30/09 FEMA spends $5M to find lost $28 billion
10/30/09 Council approves sculpture, film series
10/29/09 Why isn't science at Homeland Security peer reviewed?
10/29/09 Earmark applicant’s complaint fuels critics
10/29/09 Clunkers: Taxpayers paid $24,000 per car
10/29/09 Stimulus dollars going to accused contractors
10/29/09 Grant to fund exploration of fossil plants in Patagonia
10/29/09 National Science Foundation funds self-help for Congress
10/29/09 UCF to build virtual New York World’s Fair
10/29/09 Gossip in the workplace: A weapon or gift?
10/28/09 Big money conferences, big-money locations
10/28/09 Report: Tsunami warning funds squandered in American Samoa
10/28/09 Romer: Impact of stimulus will level off next year
10/28/09 Jobless losing streak goes on
10/28/09 Study: Amtrak loss comes to $32 per passenger
10/28/09 SAFELINK WIRELESS
10/28/09 Providing cellphones for the poor
10/28/09 CMF Study Finds Online Town Halls Increase Trust in Member - Briefing this Friday, Oct. 30
10/28/09 Social media provides a pulse
10/27/09 Audit says Dallas Housing Authority subsidized deceased clients
10/27/09 San Francisco's windfall formula
10/27/09 Current record
10/27/09 Dead woman gets federal stimulus check
10/27/09 Medicare Fraud
10/27/09 GAO report: Millions in fraud, drug abuse clogs Medicaid
10/26/09 Fire department eyes dealing with absences from flu
10/26/09 State’s first 'vinegary' opens in Sandhills
10/26/09 House subcommittee plans Honolulu junket to check on stimulus spending
10/26/09 A congressman, a lobbying firm and a swift path to earmarks
10/26/09 Energy Dept. aid for Scientists on the edge
10/26/09 Public favors internet town hall meetings
10/26/09 A Web of trust
10/26/09 Study: Online chats time well-spent for several lawmakers
10/26/09 Hamilton gets a stimulus to keep an eye out for graffiti
10/22/09 Audit: Department of Human Services misspent millions
10/22/09 Heritage groups get stimulated
10/22/09 Hear our words
10/22/09 Grants aid Tlingit language, culture education
10/22/09 New federal grant boosts Wisconsin’s specialty crops
10/22/09 $2.6 million in federal grants will promote Washington agriculture
10/22/09 Gettysburg Battlefield superintendent reassigned after leak of porn memo
10/22/09 The scenic Strip
10/20/09 Feds scrutinize Oklahoma City’s ‘Weed and Seed’
10/20/09 Beach repair funding chopped
10/20/09 Another UCD employee accused of public funds misuse
10/20/09 New study finds that internet town hall meetings increase constituent trust, perception of members of Congress
10/20/09 Field Study: Just How Relevant Is Political Science?
10/20/09 D.C. officials to scrutinize spending by AIDS groups
10/20/09 'It doesn't seem right'
10/20/09 Earmark probe focusing on former aide to Visclosky
10/20/09 Energy Star appliances may not all be efficient, audit finds
10/19/09 $2.3 million in federal stimulus money is going to pay for Tampa Bay area beauty school tuition
10/19/09 Florida's jobless rate hits 11 percent as public toll worsens
10/19/09 Khush Announces Its Reverse Karaoke iPhone Application LaDiDa Has Been Approved by Apple
10/19/09 Report ignored explicit images found on park official's computer
10/19/09 Staggering need, striking neglect
10/19/09 $400 per gallon gas to drive debate over cost of war in Afghanistan
10/19/09 Federal deficit hits all-time high $1.42 trillion
10/19/09 Cash for clubbers
10/15/09 Bumper crop of billboards
10/15/09 Leaders to discuss tolls on 'free' highways
10/15/09 Carp catch in Utah could reach 6 million pounds
10/15/09 Ex-Air Force official gets six months in case involving Murtha earmark
10/15/09 U.S. troop funds diverted to pet projects
10/15/09 Earmarks sap energy chief's priorities
10/15/09 Rabbits deposit radioactive clues on the landscape
10/14/09 N.J. wins big in federal beach-fill program
10/14/09 Political scientists fight to keep federal grants
10/14/09 Coburn warns of a blockade of spending bills
10/14/09 F.D.A. reveals it fell to a push by lawmakers
10/14/09 Soon, turning RTA buses will be talking to pedestrians
10/14/09 Fed grant a boon to bug collection
10/14/09 Seeking Privacy In The Clouds: Research Aims At Isolating Social Network Information From 'Control Of A Central Entity'
10/14/09 Taxpayers foot bill for missing items
10/13/09 Some City Park rebuilding spending questioned by federal audit; park to appeal the findings
10/13/09 Grand Parkway stretch in W. Harris Co. not so shovel-ready after all
10/13/09 Council members question streetcar funding
10/13/09 Data call into question HIV study results
10/13/09 Some lawmakers frown on museum spending
10/13/09 Study: U.S. parents respond quickly to trendy baby names
10/9/09 California spends millions in late-payment fees
10/9/09 Controllers: FAA's computers prone to problems
10/9/09 INTERIOR: BLM employees too cozy with advocacy groups -- IG
10/9/09 INTERIOR: Control of guns must be improved -- IG
10/9/09 U.S. mortgage backer may need bailout, experts say
10/9/09 New USDA research agency already wants more money
10/9/09 Humble Md. park typifies shift from scenic to cerebral
10/9/09 Bug splatter on your car's windshield is a treasure trove of genomic biodiversity
10/9/09 Ex-Staffers Winning Defense Panel Pork, Study Finds
10/9/09 Morning Business: Just Because the Company Vanished ...
10/8/09 Firefighters lose large U.S. grant to ACORN
10/8/09 FAA stimulus recipients got low priority ratings
10/8/09 Critics say Bennett funding shift short-changes troops
10/8/09 Critics blast $3M mining handout
10/8/09 Prof warns of risks hiding on social network sites
10/8/09 Coburn offers a civics lesson
10/8/09 Senator Proposes an End to Federal Support for Political Science
10/2/09 Grant allows children to create lacrosse exhibit
10/2/09 Does Birth Order Determine Willingness to Take Economic Risks?
10/2/09 Feds set aside $4.8 million for LBI beach replenishment
10/2/09 Mikulski earmarks go to top campaign contributors
10/2/09 Kerry asks $20m for Kennedy institute
10/2/09 Even in time of war, 'pork' still reigns
10/1/09 Holmes pushes for records in $13M computer contract
10/1/09 Senate approves stopgap to keep gov't running
10/1/09 Some question stimulus projects' impact on N.C.
10/1/09 Clinton site gets a taste of the stimulus pie
10/1/09 Grant gives Grateful Dead archive new life online