Oct 07 2010
CLARIFICATION - S.3317, the Haiti Empowerment, Assistance, and Rebuilding Act vs. FY 2010 Humanitarian Funding Provided to Date:
S. 3317, the Haiti Empowerment, Assistance, and Rebuilding Act sponsored by Senator John Kerry (D-MA) was introduced on May 5, 2010. This bill authorizes $500 million in new spending for Fiscal Year 2011 and does not affect the appropriated humanitarian funds provided to Haiti for FY 2010.
The total amount of USAID, State, and DoD humanitarian assistance to Haiti already provided is $1,139,632,618. FY 2010 funds have been previously appropriated for Haiti relief, making it impossible for this money to be held. Therefore, claims that this money is being blocked by a lone Senator, are false. The State Department is expediting the aid to Haiti but that the lack of this authorization bill is not holding up their delivery of relief funding to Haiti. To say that S.3317 is holding up aid to Haiti is a mischaracterization of the situation.
Click here for the State Department document outlining the FY 2010 Supplemental Appropriations Plan for Haiti.
Click here to read the State Department's letter to Senators Inouye, Cochran, Gregg and Leahy, notifying the Appropriations Committee of the spending plan for Haiti included in the Supplemental Appropriations Act of 2010.
Click here for USAID’s Haiti Earthquake Fact Sheet, detailing FY 2010 Funding Provided to Haiti to Date.
As written, S.3317 does not reduce spending by other government programs to pay for this new spending but instead adds to our national debt. Dr. Coburn wants to approve additional funds without increasing the deficit and without creating duplicative roles. Millions in wasteful, unnecessary, and duplicative spending programs have been identified at the State Department, in areas that much lower in priority than aid to Haiti.
Speculation that Senator Coburn placed a "secret hold" on a bill that is consequently preventing funds from being sent to Haiti is entirely fabricated. As previously stated, Senator Coburn's hold on the Kerry bill is in no way secret and has no effect on FY2010 funds that are supposed to be sent to Haiti from the State Department. At the beginning of each session, Senator Coburn notifies every senator through a letter (posted on this website), that he intends to block any bill from being hotlined that adds to the deficit. For additional information on the purpose and procedure of "holds", click here.
Senator Coburn's letter to Senate Minority Leader McConnell notifying leadership of his concerns regarding S.3317:
The Honorable Mitch McConnell
Senate Minority Leader
United States Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
Dear Senator McConnell,
I request that I be consulted before the Senate enters into any unanimous consent agreements regarding S. 3317, the Haiti Empowerment, Assistance, and Rebuilding Act of 2010.
There is no question we should do everything we can to assist our neighbors in Haiti seeking to recover from the devastating earthquake that killed and injured hundreds of thousands and left a million people homeless. I do not object to fulfilling our pledge to assist Haiti recover. However, I believe our charity today should not come at the expense of the next generation. Therefore, any additional aid we provide must be paid for with cuts to lower priority programs elsewhere within the federal government's bloated $3.7 trillion annual budget.
The Haiti Empowerment, Assistance, and Rebuilding Act authorizes $500 million in aid to Haiti for Fiscal Year 2011. The legislation as written does not reduce spending elsewhere in the government to pay for this aid. I feel that any future levels of aid to continue the reconstruction and rebuilding after the earthquake that hit earlier this year must come from eliminating or reducing lower priority programs at the State Department and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). At this time, when our nation is projected to add more than a trillion dollars a year to our already unsustainable $13.4 trillion national debt, it is irresponsible to authorize any new spending that is not paid for because the end result will be a lower standard of living for the United States and an inability for our nation to assist others when disasters and other crises occur in the future.
Unfortunately, some misinformed members of the media have stated that my objection to this bill is preventing aid from getting to Haiti and that Haiti has not received aid from the United States. This is clearly not the case. As you know, Congress has already appropriated over $1.1 billion in emergency aid for Haiti in the Fiscal Year 2010 Supplemental Bill (Public Law 111-212). According to the United States Agency for International Development’s website, as of September 24, 2010 the United States government had provided $1.1 billion in humanitarian assistance to Haiti for the earthquake.1
In addition to these amounts, Congress has provided $770 million in the Fiscal Year 2010 Supplemental bill to Haiti through the Economic Support Fund and another $147.6 million under the International Narcotics Control and Law Enforcement for further emergency relief, rehabilitation, and reconstruction aid to Haiti. Section 1007 of the law stipulates however, that this money cannot be obligated until the Secretary of State reports to the House and Senate Appropriations Committees on two matters: the United States will consult the Haitian government and local organizations on how the money will be spent and that clear and achievable goals and oversight controls have been established in writing to govern the spending of the money. Despite the fact that more than 10 weeks have passed since this bill was passed into law the Secretary of State appears to have fulfilled that condition only this week. While I am disappointed that executive branch bureaucracy seems to have delayed the ability of Haitians to begin long-term reconstruction, I am pleased that the aid that Congress appropriated months ago can finally move forward.
I will continue to work with the sponsors of S. 3317 to eliminate lower priority programs at the State Department that can and should be ended in order to pay for long-term reconstruction aid to Haiti. Thank you for protecting my rights regarding S. 3317, the Haiti Empowerment, Assistance, and Rebuilding Act of 2010.
Senator Tom Coburn, M.D.
(Click here for a PDF version of the letter)