(WASHINGTON, D.C.) – U.S. Senators Tom Coburn, M.D. (R-OK), John Barrasso, M.D. (R-WY), John Boozman, O.D. (R-AR), Rand Paul, M.D. (R-KY) today sent Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Administrator Marilyn Tavenner a letter questioning CMS’ plan to perform front-end testing of the ICD-10 billing code system during the week of March 3, 2014.
“Given the size and scope of the potential transition to ICD-10, the brevity and limited scope of this test is worrisome. This change will impact millions of physicians and patients, and hundreds of billions of dollars in payments that flow through Medicare and Medicaid. Other major federal IT projects--such as the implementation of Healthcare.gov--have demonstrated the importance of thorough pre-testing every aspect of new systems, both the front-end and back-end components. System-wide errors and delay could adversely impact both patients’ own pocketbooks and provider cash flows,” the Senate doctors wrote.
The Senate doctors previously introduced the Cutting Costly Codes Act, S. 972, which would prohibit HHS from moving forward with the ICD-10 transition.
The full letter is below:
February 18, 2014
Marilyn Tavenner, Administrator
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20201
Dear Administrator Tavenner:
We write with concern about the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) plan to perform front-end testing of the ICD-10 billing code system during the week of March 3, 2014. Given the size and scope of the potential transition to ICD-10, the brevity and limited scope of this test is worrisome. This change will impact millions of physicians and patients, and hundreds of billions of dollars in payments that flow through Medicare and Medicaid. Other major federal IT projects--such as the implementation of Healthcare.gov--have demonstrated the importance of thorough pre-testing every aspect of new systems, both the front-end and back-end components. System-wide errors and delay could adversely impact both patients’ own pocketbooks and provider cash flows. In fact, CMS’ own documentation warns providers to “[e]stablish an emergency fund to cover unexpected costs and possible reimbursement delays.”
The significance of this transition can hardly be overstated. The economic impact of the ICD-10 transition on insurers and medical providers will be billions of dollars. The Association of Health Insurance Plans has estimated the total cost just for health insurance companies could be as high as $3 billion. A recent report to the American Medical Association found the impact of the transition to be $83,290 for a small practice and $2.7 million for a large one. Before either Medicare or Medicaid could conceivably transition to any new diagnostic coding method, CMS must establish clear metrics and perform system-wide tests to certify its readiness.
We ask you would assist our oversight of CMS’ planned transition to the ICD-10 coding system by answering the following questions:
1. What metrics will CMS use to evaluate the success of the ICD-10 testing period in March? What are the targets CMS has set for each of these metrics to determine whether the testing period was successful?
2. Will the testing period allow Medicare providers to test accurate and prompt claim adjudication? If not, does CMS plan on executing more testing periods before full implementation (currently scheduled for October 1, 2014) to ensure claims can be accurately submitted and paid under ICD-10?
3. Before full implementation, does CMS plan to test the appeal process for claims submitted due to incorrect ICD-10 codes as providers and staff transition to the new system?
4. When does CMS plan to release results from the testing period to the public, so that providers and other entities may make necessary changes to their systems?
5. How will CMS measure the ICD-10 readiness of Medicare Administrative Contractors (MAC) and state Medicaid agencies before full implementation? Will CMS require MACs and Medicaid to demonstrate successful end-to-end testing before all providers have to switch to ICD-10? What is the current ICD-10 readiness of these entities?
6. Provide a list of any internal or third-party testing CMS has scheduled before full implementation of the ICD-10 coding system.
7. Will CMS perform full testing of Recovery Audit Contractors (RAC), the Fraud Prevention System (FPS), and other anti-fraud efforts to ensure full capability to perform anti-fraud investigations? If so, what metrics and targets will CMS use to ensure ICD-10 readiness of RACs and the FPS?
8. When will CMS release a crosswalk of Local Coverage Determinations and all other Medicare claim transaction edits associated with ICD-10 codes?
9. How often has CMS studied the ICD-10 readiness of the providers and other third parties? What industry analyses or surveys is CMS relying on for information on the ICD-10 readiness of providers and other third parties?
10. Has studied CMS the impact the ICD-10 transition may have on upcoding? Describe the results of any findings.
Thank you for your cooperation in our review. Given the imminence of the testing period, we respectfully request you would submit answers no later than February 26, 2014.
Tom A. Coburn, M.D. Rand Paul, M.D. U.S. Senator U.S. Senator
John Barrasso, M.D. John Boozman, O.D. U.S. Senator U.S. Senator
|10/23/12||Dr. Coburn Sends Letter to Governor Fallin Highlighting Concerns With Potential Medicaid Expansion|
|10/3/12||Dr. Coburn's Letter to USDA Secretary Vilsack Regarding Regulations on School Lunches|
|9/13/12||Dr. Coburn's Amendments to the Veterans Job Corps Act of 2012|
|9/13/12||Social Security Disability Programs: Improving the Quality of Benefit Award Decisions|
|6/19/12||Farm Bill Amendments Update|
|6/12/12||Dr. Coburn's Amendments to the S. 3240, Farm Bill|
|1/30/12||Dr. Coburn Filed the Following Amendments to the STOCK Act|
|1/9/12||Senators Coburn & Scott Brown Send Letter to CMS Acting Administrator Asking on Implementing Recommendations to Reduce Medicare Fraud|
|7/27/11||9,000,000,000,000 Ways to Balance the Budget|
|7/22/11||Dr. Coburn on C-SPAN's Washington Journal This Morning|
|4/13/11||New Report Reveals Overbilling of Treasury Department by Law Firms, Misuse of TARP Funds|
|4/4/11||Dr. Coburn's amendments to cut spending by $20 billion|
|11/17/10||Today, Dr. Coburn filed two amendments to the Food Safety bill|
|11/10/10||Earmark Myths and Realities|
|10/26/10||What Others Are Saying About "Grim Diagnosis"|
|10/7/10||Dr. Coburn Not Holding Aid to Haiti|
|10/4/10||HHS ADMINISTRATIVE FAILURE|
|2/22/10||Guns in Parks Fact Sheet|
|12/21/09||Coburn Highlights Government Waste and the Need for Greater Congressional Oversight|
|12/6/09||Senate Health Care Bill Costs Taxpayers $6.8 million per word|
|12/3/09||Coburn Amendments to the Democrat Health Care Bill|
|11/18/09||Coburn's efforts to improve the Caregiver and Veterans Omnibus Health Services Act|
|11/5/09||Facts about the Veterans Caregiver Bill|
|10/14/09||Medicaid Malpractice: New CRS Memo Confirms Medicaid Patients Have Higher Rate of Infant Mortality|
|10/7/09||Commerce, Justice & Science Appropriations Bill Amendments and Background|
|8/6/09||Clunkers for Charity|
|8/4/09||Coburn Amendments to the Agriculture Appropriations Bill|
|6/16/09||Dr. Coburn Releases Stimulus Oversight Report|
|6/2/09||Coburn Amendments to the Family Smoking and Prevention Act|
|5/12/09||Coburn Gun Amendments 1067 and 1068|
|5/5/09||Coburn Offers Amendment to Dispose of Unneeded Federal Buildings|
|5/1/09||OMB Responds to Coburn's Letter on Transparency|
|4/22/09||Coburn Amendments to The Fraud Enforcement and Recovery Act|
|3/31/09||$3.9 trillion 2010 Budget Resolution Amendments and Highlights|
|3/17/09||Omnibus Lands Package, AKA Anti-Stimulus, Returns to Senate|
|3/2/09||Coburn Corruption and Waste Elimination Amendments|
|3/2/09||Omnibus Highlights and Numbers|
|1/29/09||Senate Rejects Opportunity to Provide Health Care to Needy Children at No Additional Cost|
|1/7/09||Senate Leaders to Kick Off New Congress with an Earmark-Laden Omnibus Lands Bill|
|10/16/08||Highlights of Senator Reid's Omnibus Lands Grab and Energy Restrictions Act Scheduled for Debate Next Month|
|9/27/08||Coburn Comments on the Fiscal Year 2009 Continuing Resolution|
|9/26/08||Reid Neglects Economy to Pursue Pet Projects|
|9/17/08||Reid's Monkey Business Continues|
|8/21/08||Coburn Applauds HHS Action on Physician Conscience Rights|
|8/1/08||Democrats Hold Civil Rights and Child Pornography Legislation as a Political Hostage|
|6/20/08||AMERICAN OIL REMAINS UNTOUCHED|
|3/14/08||Dr. Coburn's Efforts Fix GINA|
|3/11/08||Coburn's Speech on the 2009 Budget|
|3/3/08||Dr. Coburn Amendment to Ensure Scientists Conduct Research, Not Politicians|
|2/14/08||Dr. Coburn's amendments to fix the broken Indian Health Care system|
|1/29/08||Dr. Coburn's Federal Land Bill Amendments|
|1/24/08||Coburn's official visit to Taiwan|
|11/8/07||Defense Conference Report Loaded with Pork|
|11/6/07||Dr. Coburn's amendments to the Farm Bill|
|11/6/07||Citizen Groups Support Coburn 'No-Bid' Earmarks Amendment|
|11/2/07||Dr. Coburn Urges Politicians to Put Patients Ahead of Politics|
|8/28/07||Congress celebrates the Year of the Golden Pig|
|3/26/07||Senate supplemental funding bill loaded with pork, non-emergency items|
|3/14/07||The 9/11 Commission bill|
|3/12/07||Senate breaking earmark moratorium, gearing up for 2008 requests|
|3/5/07||Sacrifice - the great American heritage|
|2/14/07||Debating the continuing resolution|
|2/7/07||What's next for the War in Iraq?|
|1/30/07||Do we need to increase the federal mininum wage?|
|1/12/07||Real reform for the Senate ethics bill|
|1/4/07||The Coburn Principles|
|12/14/06||109th Congress Convenes|
|11/16/06||Coburn amendments to the Agriculture Appropriations bill|
|9/26/06||Ryan White CARE Act Reauthorization|
|9/26/06||President Bush Signs Coburn/Obama Transparency Act|
|8/23/06||Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act|
|8/2/06||Coburn amendments to the Department of Defense Appropriations bill|
|7/17/06||Major Points For Ethical Stem Cell Research and Against Embryonic Stem Cell Research|
|7/14/06||Stem Cell Facts and Resources|
|7/12/06||Coburn amendments to Homeland Security appropriations bill|
|6/22/06||Coburn amendments to Defense authorization bill|
|6/9/06||Improve Access, Quality of Health Care|
|6/7/06||Stop the Senate from approving the Native Hawaiian Government Reform Act|
|6/7/06||Senate rejects Marriage Protection Amendment|
|5/2/06||Stop the Senate from approving non-emergency projects in the emergency supplemental|
|12/14/05||Dr. Coburn letter to HHS on Ryan White CARE Act formulas and ADAP funding|